Mixing a synthetic blend (which is part conventional oil and part synthetic) with fully synthetic oil won’t damage your engine.
All motor oils on the market today (synthetic, blends, or conventional) are compatible with each other to meet API and SAE standards.
But here’s the catch:
- The performance of the oil in your engine will drop to the level of the lesser-quality oil in the mix.
- The benefits of full synthetic, like extended drain intervals, cleaner operation, and better wear protection, will be diluted.
So, yes, it’s safe in a pinch. But it’s not ideal as a long-term practice.
When is it Okay to Mix Them?
You might mix synthetic blend and full synthetic oil in cases like:
- Topping off between oil changes if you’re running low
- You’re on the road and only have access to one type
- You’re switching from synthetic blend to full synthetic and need to gradually transition
It’s fine to do this occasionally. But if your goal is maximum engine protection, it’s better to stick with one type, preferably fully synthetic.
Will Mixing Affect Oil Life or Performance?
Yes, it can. Mixing oil types may affect:
- Viscosity stability, especially under high heat or cold starts
- Oxidation resistance, meaning the oil may degrade faster
- Additive balance, since each formulation includes different detergents, dispersants, and anti-wear compounds
This can result in shorter drain intervals and slightly lower performance, especially if the blend is heavier on conventional oil.
Keep in mind, if you’re driving in cold Canadian winters or the high heat of southern U.S. highways, using a consistent, fully synthetic oil will better protect your engine in those extreme conditions.
My Experience Mixing Oil Types
Years ago, I used to mix whatever I had on hand. Sometimes it worked fine, other times I noticed the engine felt rougher or required more frequent changes.
Since switching to AMSOIL Signature Series, I’ve never looked back. It delivers such consistent performance and longevity that I no longer worry about mixing, topping off, or frequent oil changes. Plus, it runs clean and smooth, no matter the season.